ANNE M. HILLMAN, PHD
  • Home
  • Constructive Theology
  • Interreligious Dialogue
  • Lay Ministry
  • Thoughts
  • About
  • Contact

Musings, Prayers, & Questions

Response to General Conference 2019

2/26/2019

1 Comment

 

My heart is broken, and I don’t yet know the way forward. This is not The United Methodist Church I love. This is not the way Christians are called to treat each other.
 
Today at the specially called General Conference of The United Methodist Church, by a vote of 438 to 384 (53.28% to 46.72%) our delegates passed what is called the Traditional Plan.  This plan keeps the condemnatory language in our Book of Discipline that declares homosexuality as “incompatible with Christian teaching,” continues to bar LGBTQ persons from being ordained, continues to forbid United Methodist clergy from officiating at same-sex weddings, and includes new mandated punishments for individuals, churches, and Annual Conferences that violate these rules.
 
The exact details aren’t fully set.  The denomination’s judicial body still needs to rule on the constitutionality of some parts of the Traditional Plan, and it unclear what all the ramifications will be.  What is clear is that The United Methodist Church missed an opportunity to demonstrate the radical, all-inclusive love of God.  Instead, a majority of delegates chose to hold tight to a narrow interpretation of biblical texts and continue to do harm to LGBTQ persons.
 
My LGBTQ friends both within and outside the UMC, I am sorry. I am sorry that those of us who want full inclusion were not able to change enough hearts and minds. I am sorry that I myself have at times assumed that this denomination I call home would, of course, do the right thing and so haven’t worked hard enough on your behalf. I am so sorry that more hurt has been done to you and done in the name of The United Methodist Church.
 
My heart is broken, and I don’t yet know the way forward. But I promise I will find a way forward and not give up on creating a church where the image of God found in all people is respected and where the God-given gifts and graces of all people can be lived into their full potential.
 
Blessings and love to you all. May you find the outlets for your anger and grief that you need, and may you never doubt that you are loved by God.  If, like me, you find great power and comfort in song, I suggest the music of Mark Miller.  Right now his song “Child of God” feels very appropriate. 

1 Comment

General Conference 2019

2/22/2019

1 Comment

 
Tomorrow is the beginning of a specially called General Conference for The United Methodist Church.  The General Conference is the only gathering of United Methodists that has the authority to make changes to the Book of Discipline, the document that governs the denomination.  Usually General Conference happens every four years, but at the 2016 General Conference, the delegates asked the Council of Bishops for help in how to move forward on the question of full inclusion of LGBTQ individuals in the denomination.  Now, in Saint Louis, Missouri from February 23-26, the same delegates that were at the 2016 General Conference will gather again to consider the report from the Council of Bishops’ Commission on a Way Forward that studied different beliefs about human sexuality and ways the denomination can structure itself in the future.
 
There’s a lot of detail to the different plans the delegates will be considering, and, as in every General Conference, there are sure to be many amendments put forward before a final vote is taken.  While there are three main plans right now, no one knows how many iterations will be proposed before sessions end on the 26th.  The ins and out of the process will be long and complicated.  Emotions are likely to be strong as delegates discuss deeply held beliefs on human sexuality that conflict with each other.
 
What this all comes down to, is The United Methodist Church is facing one of its most important discussions on how it plans to be the church.  Will we become inclusive, recognizing that God’s love is for all people, that the spiritual gifts of all God’s children should be honored, and their life events should be honored?  We will continue to place greater restrictions on the participation of one group of people, excluding them from serving as ordained leaders, barring them from consecrating their loving relationships in our church buildings?
 
I don’t know how things will turn out.  I don’t know if The United Methodist Church will be recognizable as the church I care deeply about, a church that strives to continue conversations between conservative and progressive while working together for justice.  I don’t know if my LGBTQ friends will continue to be harmed by the denomination I call home.  I don’t know if I will be able to continue to call this denomination my home.
 
I do know this – God loves all people.  God stands with all people searching for justice. Whatever happens at General Conference, there are many Christians who will continue to show their love for God by loving who God loves: everyone.
1 Comment

    Anne Hillman

    I am a constructive theologian and United Methodist Deaconess

    Archives

    June 2020
    April 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018

    Categories

    All
    Advent
    Christmas
    Easter
    Empire
    Justice
    LGBTQ
    Privilege
    Racism
    Thanksgiving
    United Methodist Church
    Worship

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Constructive Theology
  • Interreligious Dialogue
  • Lay Ministry
  • Thoughts
  • About
  • Contact